**Fact-Checking the Smithtown News: Freight Train Yard Zoning & Public Opposition*
- Toby Carlson
- Feb 5
- 2 min read
**Fact-Checking the Smithtown News: Freight Train Yard Zoning & Public Opposition**
**Claim 1: "Construction of the freight train yard does not require town zoning approval."**
✔️ **Verdict: True**
The Surface Transportation Board (STB) **granted Townline Rail Terminal, LLC an exemption** under **49 U.S.C. 10502**, meaning **the project does not require local zoning approval**. The STB has jurisdiction over rail-related projects that impact interstate commerce, and in this case, it **overrides town zoning laws**.
📌 **Sources:** [Federal Register STB Decision](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/08/20/2024-18538/townline-rail-terminal-llc-construction-and-operation-exemption-in-suffolk-county-ny) | [STB Official Statement](https://www.stb.gov/pr-24-03)
---
**Claim 2: "Community opposition to the project is overwhelming."**
⚠️ **Verdict: Misleading**
The article implies that **nearly all residents oppose the project**, but the **actual data shows a divided response**:
- **44 opposition letters** were submitted from Fort Salonga, Commack, and Northport.
- Some groups **support the project**, including business and trade organizations who advocate for **rail-based transport as an eco-friendly alternative** to trucking.
- The STB reviewed opposition petitions and **denied a request for further environmental review**, stating there was **no new evidence** to justify additional study.
📌 **Sources:** [Newsday](https://www.newsday.com/long-island/towns/kings-park-rail-yard-xodku761) | [STB Response to Opposition](https://lilifepolitics.com/news/long-island-news/board-denies-petition-against-rail-yard)
---
**Claim 3: "The proposed rail yard will harm the environment."**
⚠️ **Verdict: Needs Context**
- The **STB Environmental Assessment** reviewed noise, dust, water contamination, and truck traffic impacts.
- **Mitigation measures** were approved to address **light pollution, water runoff, and truck routing**.
- **No significant environmental harm** was found in the STB Final Review, but **some community concerns remain**.
📌 **Sources:** [Federal Register STB Decision](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/08/20/2024-18538/townline-rail-terminal-llc-construction-and-operation-exemption-in-suffolk-county-ny)
---
**Final Verdict on the Article**
The Smithtown News article presents **some accurate information but frames it in a way that overstates opposition and environmental risks while omitting STB findings and mitigation efforts**. The zoning claim is **accurate**, but opposition and environmental concerns **lack full context**.
📌 **Final Verdict: ❌ Misleading / Needs Context**
---
**Conclusion**
While the freight train yard is a **controversial project**, it is essential to **present the facts objectively**. The **STB has made its decision**, mitigation measures are in place, and while **opposition exists, it is not universal**. The Real Smithtown News will continue to **fact-check claims and ensure transparency in local reporting.**
🔹 **Stay informed. Seek facts. Demand accountability.**
Comments